An Iconic Fantasy Baseball Community
Moderator: Baseball Moderators
BlueJaysFan wrote:Its hard to say who will be better next season, but I personally like Weaver more than JJ. Now, thats based on how they played, or haven't played this year (Weaver leads the AL in ERA, and has other great stats). At the beginning of the season, I would have drafted JJ first, but I think Weaver is no fluke and can easily have another season like this next year. I'm not sure Lomo is an upgrade to victorino, but I can see your thinking. Getting Chacin for the rest of the season isn't bad; he can potentially be your 10th keeper. So what I would do is, make the deal but take out Weaver and JJ. But, if you think JJ will be better than Weaver next year, I'd do the deal as is.
Bolthead04 wrote:I actually love the deal as is. I do believe JJ will put a better full season together than Weaver next year, even with injury concerns to be had. I also like switching Victorino for LoMo and Chacin.
As for details, I seriously doubt Weaver will throw a repeat next year, and I believe the fish will be the breakout candidates of 2012 (to be the next version of the 2011 pirates perhaps?) (Especially with the trade deadline looming and the team wanting to move stock...) As for Chacin, I think he will be a very solid pitcher. Ubaldo'esque? Who knows? But, I like his pitching style and I like his team. He will be solid.
Really, if this is on the table to accept, go for it. It helps both sides and gives you a solid set of keepers for next year. I think this is a very solid deal for you.
Thanks for the help on mine! Cheers!
plapre3 wrote:Should I deal my Jered Weaver and Shane Victorino for his Josh Johnson, Logan Morrison, and Jholys Chacin?
kaiser wrote:I'd want the combination of Weaver and Shane over JJ, LoMo and Chacin. If I could be confident in JJ actually playing a full season, I would porbably take that side, but at this point, I just dont have that confidence.
Help with this Votto/Wright trade?
Users browsing this forum: cinfante54, kidsilk, Surfs up and 18 guests