I think Tulo would bring back a better piece than Jose though. You already have Cano at 2B, which means you're getting OF-like production in terms of power, at a middle infield spot. I'd keep Reyes so you have a solid SB core of Reyes/Kemp/Ellsbury.
I'd use Tulo (who usually has a hot second half, which you'll want to play up), for someone like Bautista (talk about injury concern sapping power), Longoria/SP, Granderson/SP, Holliday.
My concern is either filling that third OF spot in place of Delmon, improving upon 3B since Wright is still a question mark and Peralta is overachieving, while adding another SP if possible.
(In reference to an Aaron Hill for David Price swap)
mpieco wrote: You're my new hero if that gets accepted.
Trade accepted! Thanks for the help!