Deal Carpenter for Ortiz?? WHIR Always

[BiGAnT]

Hey guys, I need HR and RBIs, and my pitching is relatively decent...any ideas on whether I can afford this trade or not, thanks! ...I give Carpenter for Ortiz where this is my team: Ortiz would play UTIL and I would trade Hart and try to get another pitcher for him:

C Yadier Molina
1B Ryan howard
2B Brandon Phillips
3B Jhonny Peralta
SS Jimmy Rollins
OF Matt Kemp
OF Rajai Davis
OF Carlos Quentin
Util Corey hart
BN Alex Rios

SP Roy Halladay
SP Chris Carpenter
SP Jair Jurrjens
RP Sergio Santos
RP Mark Melancon
P Gio Gonzales
P Brian Matusz
P Charlie Morton
P Aaron Crow
P Mike Adams
P Brandon Lyon
DL Brandon McCarthy

[whitheadsuxs]

i love what youll be getting try to do a 2 for 2 with him add hart and take a decent pitcher off him to this same guy


viewtopic.php?t=432949

[ATLbraves]

i love what youll be getting try to do a 2 for 2 with him add hart and take a decent pitcher off him to this same guy


viewtopic.php?t=432949

Yeah I agree, if you are trading Carpenter you are going to need a pitcher in return. Try and get a pitcher in the deal too.



help with mine please:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=432947

[BiGAnT]

i love what youll be getting try to do a 2 for 2 with him add hart and take a decent pitcher off him to this same guy


viewtopic.php?t=432949

Yeah I agree, if you are trading Carpenter you are going to need a pitcher in return. Try and get a pitcher in the deal too.



help with mine please:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=432947

Heres the problem...here's his pitching staff: Lincecum, Lee, Price and then Colby Lewis, John Danks and Clayton Richard. Who do I ask for? Obviously not any of the first three because that would be a no automatically...and also even though it looks like he doesn't, he is lacking in SP because of how awful his other guys have been which is why he wants Carpenter in the first place. Any suggestions, or should I just stick with the 1 for 1 and try my hand at swapping hart for another SP with another team? Thanks guys, and I'm getting to your posts right now

[ATLbraves]

I would ask for Colby Lewis or John Danks. You dont think he would trade you either of them?

[BiGAnT]

I would ask for Colby Lewis or John Danks. You dont think he would trade you either of them?

I'm saying I think he would do that but I was asking do I really want any of those pitchers for Hart? Lewis can be very solid and is on a good team...Danks can be shaky but just pitched a gem so could be turning it around...and Richard has the best ballpark but is on a horrible team...but my first pick would have been Lewis too (if not I'll shoot for Danks I think)

[MadDog36]

Colby Lewis and David Ortiz for Chris Carpenter and Corey Hart is a good move.

[BiGAnT]

Colby Lewis and David Ortiz for Chris Carpenter and Corey Hart is a good move.

He didn't go for it...should I try with Danks or Richard? Or do you think I should do the one for one with Ortiz and Carpenter and then shop Hart around for a 1for1 for another SP (this kid doesn't really need more OFs so I think thats why he didn't go for it) but I could probably sell him to someone who needs an OF and snag a SP for him?

[GardnerRunsRampant]

Colby Lewis and David Ortiz for Chris Carpenter and Corey Hart is a good move.

He didn't go for it...should I try with Danks or Richard? Or do you think I should do the one for one with Ortiz and Carpenter and then shop Hart around for a 1for1 for another SP (this kid doesn't really need more OFs so I think thats why he didn't go for it) but I could probably sell him to someone who needs an OF and snag a SP for him?

I prefer Danks to Lewis anyway. If he doesn't accept that, just do Ortiz for Carpenter. I'm sure someone would trade a pitcher better than Richard for Hart.

Ortiz has been swinging a good bat in a good lineup this year. I like what he adds to your team over Carpenter.

Please help in mine: viewtopic.php?t=433000

[ATLbraves]

Colby Lewis and David Ortiz for Chris Carpenter and Corey Hart is a good move.

He didn't go for it...should I try with Danks or Richard? Or do you think I should do the one for one with Ortiz and Carpenter and then shop Hart around for a 1for1 for another SP (this kid doesn't really need more OFs so I think thats why he didn't go for it) but I could probably sell him to someone who needs an OF and snag a SP for him?

I prefer Danks to Lewis anyway. If he doesn't accept that, just do Ortiz for Carpenter. I'm sure someone would trade a pitcher better than Richard for Hart.

Ortiz has been swinging a good bat in a good lineup this year. I like what he adds to your team over Carpenter.

Please help in mine: viewtopic.php?t=433000

^^^^i completely agree with this. If he won't trade you Danks then just do Ortiz for Carpenter straight up, and try to shop Corey Hart for another SP.