An Iconic Fantasy Baseball Community
Moderator: Baseball Moderators
rjforlife wrote:Gordon/Rasmus is basically a wash at this point. I like Colby more but he doesn't get it done.
Joyce for Sandoval is heavily against you, despite your hopes on Sandoval's triumphant return.
Jurrjens for Marcum is heavily in your favor, K's being the major factor.
In total, the deal is fair, but you can do better. You aren't selling high enough on JJ and Joyce. I think you should, and this deal is close, I would just like to see Sandoval or Rasmus upgraded or combined into one much better player.
misterf wrote:thanks for the help on mine.
I think the pitchers or more or a less a wash. They both have their pros/cons....and some will like JJ....others will like Marcum (for the record, i like Marcum better, but it's close).....but really they are both solid #2 fantasy pitchers.
So the trade really comes down to the hitters.
I think Joyce is probably the best hitter in the deal (I rank Marcum as the best player in the deal). But it really comes down to how you rate Pablo. If you are in the camp that thinks he will be back in a week or two and pick up hitting just like he was in April, then the deal is great for you.
If you are concerned that Pablo will revert to last season's suck-itude (yeah...its a word).....then it is probably safer to pass on the trade.
As a Giants fan, I have not heard any news that Pablo has packed on any pounds....so i am will to be bullish on Pablo and recommend the deal............
.....but, really, this is a very even trade.....with equal risk/reward on both sides.
If you like Pablo, go for it......................if Pablo scares you, pass
Users browsing this forum: JRM4833 and 9 guests