Page 1 of 1

Heath Bell or Kimbrel...

PostPosted: Wed Jun 01, 2011 6:00 pm
by mchapple78
Being offered a trade and have choice of Kimbrel or Bell at closer.

I like kimbrel's K's but like Bell's ERA.

LOoking for saves more than the other numbers, so who do you like better???

Re: Heath Bell or Kimbrel...

PostPosted: Wed Jun 01, 2011 7:26 pm
by oconnellk22
Bell even though he is on the Padres still saved 47 games last year. Id go with him even though i like Kimbrel alot ( have him on a team) just because he is proven and this is Kimbrel's first year as a full time closer.

Re: Heath Bell or Kimbrel...

PostPosted: Wed Jun 01, 2011 8:23 pm
by baegames
I think Kimbrel is slightly more likely to lose his job due to ineffectiveness at some point, but Bell could be traded to become a setup man on a contender. He also could become a closer on a contender. I would expect Kimbrel to have more saves if that is all you care about, but he will have more bumps in the road than Bell.

Help with mine:

viewtopic.php?t=432277

Re: Heath Bell or Kimbrel...

PostPosted: Wed Jun 01, 2011 9:41 pm
by whitheadsuxs
this isnt even a thought heath bells adp was 75 and kimbrel was nobody before this year bell has the most saves since 09 he has a 109 saves and has more than a strikeout an inning this kid is eric gange nasty not that nasty but super nasty

Re: Heath Bell or Kimbrel...

PostPosted: Wed Jun 01, 2011 9:48 pm
by ryetoast93
I think everyone seems to forget that the Padres are SIGNIFICANTLY worse this year. Like way worse. Bell saved 47 games on a team that barely missed the playoffs last year(albeit in a terrible division). The Padres might not win many more than that this year. However, Bell is going to get every save chance, and is still the best option here. Plus he has next to no competition. No one in San Diego is beating down the door for the closers job, and in Atlanta, Jonny Venters has a sub-1 ERA and WHIP. Bell is the safe bet here.

Re: Heath Bell or Kimbrel...

PostPosted: Wed Jun 01, 2011 9:51 pm
by whitheadsuxs
oh yea and like the dude said the padres suck if they do win its by less than 3 usually so basically all the games they win except ten he gets a save oppo they prolly will win 65 games

Re: Heath Bell or Kimbrel...

PostPosted: Thu Jun 02, 2011 1:04 am
by HOOTIE
whitheadsuxs wrote:this isnt even a thought heath bells adp was 75 and kimbrel was nobody before this year bell has the most saves since 09 he has a 109 saves and has more than a strikeout an inning this kid is eric gange nasty not that nasty but super nasty

ADP really has no bearing.
Bell is better, but he will get moved, and it's not a lock he will close.
I take Kimbrel.