I would go, in this order:
Matusz is straight skilled, the guy is amazing and coming back soon. Zimmerman has the second most potential here. Hudson has shown how dominant he can be and I think even with low K's will be very valuable. Bedard is playing great, but he will break down, a nice stopgap. Dempster will get you K's, but he will also balloon you ERA once every other week at least.
Help on mine?viewtopic.php?t=431794