This is the 2nd post today...involving Lincecum...that I'm considering moving from my "never trade an elite position player for a pitcher".
Car-Go's my boy...love the guy. But, he's having a predictable sophomore slump and now a groin pull (and those scare me!). You can move BJ to the OF and Gabby to the UTI. And adding Timmy to your SP's makes you nearly unbeatable there. Tim's a proven top-3-5 SP and Car-Go's given us a 1-year sample.
If Car-Go was looking good and totally healthy, I'd say no. Given that there are some legit concerns there and you can just set your SP's and forget about it after this deal, I'm leaning towards yes.