the big kicker hear is if Hernandez goes down (which is likely) Hanigan would be gold in that lineup, I agree that outside that big 4-4 day after opening day, Hanigan hasn't been much.
The other factor in this is we use a DH spot for our lineups and they player has to have DH services (min. of 10 games this year) or 20 games last year. I currently have 3 DH eligible guys, (V-Mart/Butler and Dan Johnson) my current setup has V-Mart @ Catcher since we start 2 there, and Butler @ 1B since we start 2 there, (A-Gon is my other 1B) and I have Dan Johnson @ DH, who has been down right AWFUL to begin this season. But I have no other options.
I could dump Johnson and move V-Mart to DH, and play Lucroy and Hanigan for my 2 Catcher slots. weak I know. but its a 15 team league where we start the following 2 Catchers 2-1B, 2-2B, 2-3B, 2-SS, 5-OF, 1-DH, 8-P.
So out of these 3 guys, who would you dump?
C - Hanigan $3
C - Lucroy $2
1B/DH - Johnson $1
Down the road I have Brennan Bosch who is 6 games shy of DH eligibility sooner the better.