I think losing Reyes would be a HUGE blow. Instead, package a Andrus with one of your starters (say, Nolasco), to net a frontliner.
Lemme know if this helps and if I can do anything else.
Columnist: Fantasy Baseball Dugout, Razzball, Dobber Baseball, FantasyBaseball.com, Pro Fantasy Baseball
Follow me on Twitter: @fantasybking
Like my Facebook Page: http://on.fb.me/l7Tv5L