Try for Haren or Cliff Lee? WHIR

[footballisbetter.com]

I have been going back and forth with this owner. He needs closers and I need a solid starter. I was thinking about countering with the following 2 offers. Which one would you prefer?

I give Paplebon and F Cordero for Cliff Lee

or

I give Marmol for Haren

Either of those trades would work under the salary cap, but I don't think we could swap anything out.

Here is my staff: (start 9, any combo)
Lester, Hellickson, Kuroda, C Lewis, P Hughes, Britton
Marmol, Paplebon, F Cordero, Hanrahan, Franklin, Contreras

[MaudDib]

I would rather get Lee plus I think you keep the best closer in Marmol.

[avsfan4ever33]

The deal for Lee is the better one for you... you're getting a superior pitcher and giving up lesser closers in return.

[footballisbetter.com]

What if I had to give up Marmol and either Paplebon or Cordero for C Lee?

Would that still be the better deal for me?

[midwestpatsfan]

IF you have to give up mamol and papelbon then I do not like the deal as much. Lee is going to be awesome but 2 studs may be too much to give up. Cordero doesn't do much for me so I like the 1st deal if you can get it.

help me?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=426989

[kaiser]

I agree that getting Lee should be your first choice, if possible. If you can give Paps and Cord to get him, I would do it. Like the other poster, I don't like giving up Marmol.

I am also fearful of Haren's 1st/2nd half splits from last year. Marmol for Haren is fair, but do the Lee deal if you can make it without including Marmol.

[CubsFan4Life23]

The first deal would suit you best...You do not want to give up both Paps and Marmol for Lee...

help please

viewtopic.php?t=426990

[FantasyMVP]

Both of those deals are awesome. Are they on the table or are you planning on offering them? I don't know if either of those deals would even be accepted.