Pick My 8th Keeper Please

[Verminator]

I lost Adam Wainwright as a keeper which is irrelevant now but like to mention to gain sympathy!

Please help me pick my 8th keeper from the following list. This is a 5x5, 12 team mixed league.

Chris Carpenter
Clay Buchholz
Colby Lewis
Grady Sizemore
Angel Pagan

I have committed to the following 7 players so far:
Votto, McCutchen, Pedroia, VMartinez, Kershaw, Prado, Soto
(I have this "thing" for Soto... call me a believer or delusional! )

[HOOTIE]

Buchholz and Sizemore let Prado go

[Dans]

I would keep Carpenter. I agree I'd probably also let Prado go and keep either Sizemore or Buchholz.

Please help me

viewtopic.php?f=26&t=423856&p=3361039#p3361039

[pizzaboy76]

Based on who you are keeping, I would go with Carpenter. He's a #1 starter and will round out your keepers nicely.

Please help;

viewtopic.php?t=423841

[Rascabuches]

I would drop Prado and keep Buchholz and Carpenter that would give u 3 top 25 starters.

[SecretAgentMan]

I would drop Prado and keep Buchholz and Carpenter that would give u 3 top 25 starters.

No way I keep Prado or Sizemore over those 2. Sizmeore can't stay healthy and Prado is a decent but not excpetional player in fantasy.

[LeftyQB]

Agree with some of the other...keep Carpenter and Buchholz.