I'm in a 12-team, ESPN standard scoring, head to head, snake draft league. You can get 1 point for beating your weekly opponent in each of 5 offensive categories: Runs, HRs, RBIs, Steals, and Avg (5 pitching categories as well but don't worry about that because I'm not keeping pitchers). We get three keepers heading into this season. You don't get penalized for keeping a higher ranked keeper versus a lower one who might give you better value. You can keep a keeper for 3 years max but I'm not putting too much weight on that factor.
My offense was stacked last year so I'm struggling to whittle my team down to 3 keepers. Who should I keep between Buster Posey, Ryan Howard, Chase Utley, Jose Bautista, Matt Holliday, and Jason Heyward?
(I'm thinking about staying away from Utley because of his injury problems this spring)