I'll be the dissenting voice here.
Jimenez is great, but lost steam by the end of last year. Now that his catcher, Miguel Olivo, is gone, I'm a bit wary of the Rockies pitching staff in general. This is the same guy who helped Greinke get a CY Young award, and now he's in Seattle (Damn you, King Felix!) While Ubaldo is good, I think he's still a bit of a question mark-commodity.
Cole Hamels has two things going for him. A ridiculous finish to last season, and the fact that he'll be going up against the 4th starter for others teams (typically). Not to mention, he'll be pitching with a chip on his shoulder since he is becoming more and more of an afterthought in the media (certainly not in Philly-we love him, but moreso around the country).
I go with Cole.
(In reference to an Aaron Hill for David Price swap)
mpieco wrote: You're my new hero if that gets accepted.
Trade accepted! Thanks for the help!