5x5 Keeper League. We keep 8 players (no restrictions). We use standard Yahoo positions plus some extra hitters (C, MI, CI, OF, OF).
I have a solid set of 6-7 keepers. I have been offered the following trades:
My Tulo for his Greinke and Reyes - This would upgrade my last keeper spot from Billingsley.
My Tulo for his Sabathia, Dunn, and D Young - This would upgrade my last 2 keeper spots from B Upton and C Billingsley.
My Tulo for his B McCann and C Carpenter - Should I even be considering this?
I'm looking to contend this season, but I'm not sure if I am getting enough in return for Tulo. I like the first deal a lot, but I don't know if Reyes will be healthy. For the second deal, I am very high on Upton, so I'm not sure if the new combo of Sabathia/Dunn/Young is better than Tulo/Upton/Bills. The third deal looks plain crappy for me.
Thoughts? WHIR 100% and quickly at that! All replies are appreciated!