wake wrote:Mookie4ever wrote:wake wrote:
It seemed obvious he was trying to cover himself. The only time someone would say, "Trust me, you'll be making a huge mistake" would be when they're mafia or if they have a special role. Since he wasn't saying what that special role specifically was (and thus revealing to the person who actually had that special role that Aqua was lying), it seemed likely he was mafia.
Of course, I ended up being wrong, but I also don't expect a regular townie to try and imply special townie status to try and save themselves. It is assumed that townies will always tell the truth.
You lost me. What special status did he imply he had or how did he imply this?Aqua wrote:Trust me. A big mistake if you let me die.
That was my read of it at least. Its sounds like Dan and Bronx picked up the same thing.
I did read it that way as well. And it's another reason why I won't be shedding any tears for Aqua, as that type of play is really not helping the town at all.
But there are two special-role townies (doctor and investigator). So if this statement from you above:
wake wrote:Since he wasn't saying what that special role specifically was (and thus revealing to the person who actually had that special role that Aqua was lying), it seemed likely he was mafia.
Is meant to imply that you're a special-role townie, then there was still a chance that Aqua was the other one. Yet you still slapped the kill vote on him before anyone could back up Lambskin's advice to slow down. Now, I'm not saying you should have believed Aqua, because I probably wouldn't have either at that point. But you were nowhere to be seen during the discussions over whether to change our votes to Aqua. Yet you swoop in after a long period of silence and put the kill vote on him...