I would keep Reyes over Hanson with 3 SP already in your 5 keepers. Was looking at a list of SP ranked #111-120, not pretty, but not awful. Including:Kazmir Happ Stauffer, Volstad, Porcello, Fister and Bergesen. Slowey, LeBlanc in the next 10.
I wouldn't go out of my way and pass on the consensus earlier pick; especially when you've already got your aces in place. You did say you started middle inf as well so yes 12 SS's, some teams could grab 2 of the top 12. Starting that many SP's is something to keep in mind every round, but I do think you need to have some top offensive options as well
If you said you had 4 hitters and wanted to take the "lower ranked" player as your 1st pitcher I could see that. But with 4 SP in 5 keepers seems like you'd struggle to compete offensively. Its all great if you can dominate in pitching, but if you have a subpar offense to go with it you usually don't have a chance to win
When asking for roster advice in these pages, remember there are thousands of different sets of league rules & many different active roster settings. If you want the best replies, be sure to include your leagues particulars in the original post