buffalobillsrul2002 wrote:Comment 3:
I also suspect Aqua, but he's normally so quiet that I'd like to see what he has to say before lynching him. But if he doesn't speak soon, I'll have to jump on the bandwagon since I haven't seen much of anything yet to indicate he's not a mafia, especially on day 2. And I think I have to agree with thedude's last comment there. I see aqua, giants, and wake as likely mafia candidates as well
This was when it was obvious that either titan or aqua was going to be lynched. Bills waited and waited and refused to lynch a mobster. So how am i more obvious than bills? You all didn't read this did you?
Here is what I said that GF got all upset about (after not doing anything all game and probably not even reading what I had written to that point):
I am going to give Lebowski, Teddy, and Aqua until tomorrow to get more involved. I said day 1 that I suspected Aqua who is playing this game much like last game (when he was mafia), so I will probably vote for aqua.
For now I will leave my vote on Titan because of his bizarre actions. If aqua has not started really taking part before tomorrow, I will probably be throwing a vote his way.
Here is what i wrote earlier on day 2:
thedude wrote: bigken117 wrote:
bigh0rt wrote:, and I'm ready to toss my vote on Teddy who has been entirely too quiet for my liking. He's begging to fly under the radar, below suspicion (and has been pretty successful thus far) and at the very least he's been the least helpful person to the town thus far.
I was just about to say the same thing. And the dead townie voted for him Day 1. unvote : Aqua
Still don't trust Aqua for the record.
When I was talking about lurker townies that I was considering voting for Teddy and Lebowski were at the top of my list. I want to see if this will make him get involved.
thedude wrote:To those people who really haven't done much today, (you know who you are) I again repeat my calls for you to weigh in on this discussion. We really aren't close to lynching anyone and need more input (1. so and we find people who may be guilty; and more important 2. so we do not act hastily and lynch some innocent townie). With this many people we should be able to put our heads together and find some mafia.
I am close to just putting a vote on one of the biggest lurkers for several reasons: first the ISK and part of the mafia are probably hiding among the lurkers; second even if you are a townie you really are not helping much so losing you would not be as big a loss to the town as losing someone who is actually contributing.
Please townie lurkers come forward and contribute. If you contribute, the mafia and ISK will not have a place to hid and will be forced into actually taking a position on something.
thedude wrote:While I shall leave my vote on steelerfan for the moment, I'd like to hear from some of the lurkers aqua (who talked some) buffalo (who was also been here occasionally), but most of all Teddy and lastings (both of whom have been completely absent for most of the two days).
Mafia and isk tend to hide in the lurkers, so there is no voting history to go on.
And if you guys are townies I want your opinions on:
Steelerfan's actions day 1
Titan's actions day 2
And jfg's theory on H0rt
As well as the other theories floating around right now.
So as I told GF on day 2. I had been consistent urging all three of the lurkers: teddy, lebo, and aqua to get involved. That post gf jumped on was just my final threat.
Here are my thoughts on aqua:
This is me and Ken day 2:
bigken117 wrote:However who's bothering me more than you and your unoriginality is Aqua. He did the vote and run on m16a last game, and he's been posting in other forums and threads but not here today. If he's a townie, why isn't he helping? I felt strongly day 1 and nothing's happened to make me change my mind
This is a good point. I am of the opinion that when you are not sure who the mafia is, look to the lurkers.
This is me day 1:
thedude wrote:I am considering voting for m16a, and I might do that later. For right now, I am going to vote aqua because he seems to be laying low agian and being quitely throwing votes on people. This is how he has played mafiaso the last couple of games. Then again, it might be that he just always plays like that and he has just happend to be mafia two out of the last three games.
This is the agruement that ken and others later adopted and nearly had aqua lynched on day 1 and was used to lynch him on day 2. It would be pretty stupid of a mafia to formulate the plan that was eventually used to lynch one of the other mafia. Now I will let the other townies formulate your own opinions on this. And I plead you to actually think through your actions rather than just following GF because he is more experienced than you are.
"I do not think baseball of today is any better than it was 30 years ago... I still think Radbourne is the greatest of the pitchers." John Sullivan 1914-Old athletes never change.