Jay, that was a really weird vote. I agree, Aqua's been pretty quiet, but at least he gave a reason. Look at wacoug's posts:
WaCougMBS wrote:Oh God, the post editing has started already, LOL
WaCougMBS wrote:The true definition of perfection! Much like those twins
WaCougMBS wrote:Definitely right up there...
...and that's it. I feel like if you were looking to vote for someone due to not having time for the game, WaCoug is the more obvious direction.
So I've been trying to make some kind of sense out of a largely useless day 1 thus far, and I have a theory. I'm probably off here, but try to bear with me.
J35J is mafia. He sees the train begin to build steam against him with 2 votes and has to deflect the attention elsewhere by voting for someone else. There is already a vote on Mookie (who I've already voiced suspicion of), but J can't vote for him because he's also mafia. J's last voting option is the vote for the quiet guy, of which we have 2: WaCoug and Aqua. If WaCoug is the 3rd mafia member, that would explain why J put in the inexplicable vote for Aqua despite WaCoug being the better choice.
Like I said, I'm just throwing a bunch of crap against a wall and seeing if anything sticks, but I feel like my logic is sound enough at this point to put a vote in for J. vote: J35J
By the way, as far as my initial suspicions of urban go, I went back and checked out old games he's played in and it seems that what he's doing in this game is pretty consistent with what he's done in the past, unlike Mookie. As of right now, he's dropped down my list of suspicious characters.