this is probably the most interesting conversation in the baseball world this year.. as far as I'm concerned it has no relevence to me as both of my leagues are keeper leagues and I have Longoria in both of them, but I still find my self having a lot of interest in the reynolds issue.
1) what is the reasoning that makes so many people so sure that he will fall off next year?
2) why are pitchers still giving him pitches to hit? I think he has proven that he will chase stuff all over the place. he is a strikeout machine.
3) if you pass on him in the 2nd round next year (most likely will be the 4th 3B drafted after Roid, Wright and Longoria), how badly are you kicking yourself if he has another year like this.
4) 3B = Roid, Wright, Longoria, Aramis, Reynolds, or you're screwed. oh wait.. Youk, forgot about Youk.. still very thin.
5) what if at the end of the season he has 50 HR's? does that change anything? how about 55?
6) this guy is an enigma.