It seemed fair to me too, but it got vetoed. I feel Cordero has a touch more value than Garza, but not by such an unreasonable degree to have the deal vetoed.
In this same League, a trade of Jenks for Pierre on May 28th was approved. Also, a deal of Wainwright/Jenks/Franklin for Guererro/Thome/McCutchen 2 weeks ago was approved.
It's a 5x5 League.
C: Iannetta, Baker
2B: Polanco, Schum
SS: Rollins, Hardy
3B: Youkilis, Reynolds
OF: Soriano, Pence, Cruz, Span, Quentin, Rivera, Winn
SP: Johan, Beckett, Garza, Danks, E. Santana
RP: Bell, Sherrill, Soriano, Downs, Frasor, MacD