Patterson is a 30/30 man waiting to happen. I don't see it happening this year but he will post 20/20. His numbers will fall something like .280- 23HR- 78rbi-90r-27sb. He is the one I would take first.
Don't steals count in your leagues? Because I don't get the Gibbins picks. He may have a couple more homers and maybe a few RBI's more then Patterson but not to many more. Where patterson will have 20 or 25 more SB's and more runs.
They are all pretty close. Gibbons is proven and he has not had any major injiry problems. Kearns is probably thee biggest injury risk, but he plays in a hitters park and has a huge ceiling. Patterson is also a super prospect.
I would glady take any of these guys as my 3rd outfielder.