advice on a trade proposal

[thekonaman]

I am in a 10 team Keeper League

My Team is below - I have been offered Travis Snider for Brian Roberts . What do you guys think ? My team is definitely in a rebuilding stage and has no shot at winning or coming close but I think Roberts could be a debatable keeper for the next 1-2 years - Is it worth the risk with Snider's upside and being the Longoria of this year?


Chris Iannetta
(Col - C)

Adrián González
(SD - 1B)

Brian Roberts
(Bal - 2B)

Edwin Encarnación
(Cin - 3B)

Alexei Ramírez
(CWS - 2B,SS,OF)

Curtis Granderson
(Det - OF)

Nelson Cruz
(Tex - OF)

Hunter Pence
(Hou - OF)

Util
Dexter Fowler
(Col - OF)

Util
J.J. Hardy
(Mil - SS)

BN
Emilio Bonifacio
(Fla - 2B,3B)

BN
Andre Ethier
(LAD - OF)

BN
Mike Aviles
(KC - 2B,SS)

BN
Lastings Milledge
(Was - OF)

BN
Dan Uggla
(Fla - 2B)

BN
Álex Rodríguez
(NYY - 3B) DL

BN
Josh Fields

[Lenny6]

It's way too early in the year to make that move. You've got a lot of other guys who could break out as well, especially in your OF already, so why not wait and see if they do rather than trading a proven commodity right now? Who knows how long it will take Snider to become an automatic keeper - you may actually prolong your rebuilding by giving up one of your best trading chips now.

You didn't list your pitchers - are they the reason why you think you have no shot of competing this year? Your offense looks decent when A-Rod comes back in a few weeks.

[sublime8414]

i agree, i would wait, as i think you could get much more than that in return for roberts. to me he's clearly a top 40 player. I'm a big snider fan, but he's just not worth as much as a roberts even in a keeper format.

mind helping with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=29&t=378758