I think either Crisp or Dukes are better options than Nady. Crisp and Dukes have shown that they can play and put up good numbers when given playing time. Encarnacion has 25+ HR talent in him and I would not just out-right drop somebody like that -- he could be packaged with another OF to bolster your OF crew overall.
Help me out? viewtopic.php?t=375014
C-BMolina 1B-Votto 2B-Utley 3B-Youk SS-Furcal LF-JDamon CF-BJUpton
RF-ARios UT-DLee BN-Scutaro,CBlake,Schumaker DL-JReyes
SP-SBaker RP-ABailey P-Saito,Hawkins,JJohnson,Dempster,Danks,JShields,Garza