Do you have additional columns for your auction value cheat sheet other than values or player rankings? What other things do you bring to your live draft? Usually I bring a cheat sheet, a blank roster sheet, and a baseball magazine.
Mostly what's already been said: list of names according to my ranking, last years stats, ADP. I break my list down into tiers. For Yahoo, I'll list their-O-rank (since that's the default ranking when you go into the draft room). I also like to have little notes by some players ("injury concern", "will start in minors", "bounce-back candidate", "breakout candidate", "closer job in jeopardy" ... stuff like that).