RedBullVodka wrote:My 2p worth:
1) Waiver wire picks that are kept should be a Round 20 pick- I think managers who pick this year's Quentin should be rewarded.
2) All waiver wire picks should be a Round 20 pick the following year - even if they were drafted by someone. They are still a waiver wire pick.
I have to disagree. If the pickup was in the draft, he should retain the round he was drafted in. If the pickup is someone who was a free agent, then waived, then picked up again, he should be a 15th rounder or something very close to that.
RedBullVodka wrote:3) I'm OK with escalation - but I think one round per season is enough.
4) I'm assuming round 1 picks just stay as round 1 forever...
"Forever" defeats the purpose of escalating. If there is escalation of 2 rounds, rounds one and two go back into the pool. I don't think it would make much sense to exempt certain rounds from escalation.