J35J wrote:Do keep in mind this is for REAL baseball not fantasy. With that said, I'm not too impressed with the list so far. #1 for me would be a staff ace as far as real baseball goes. I think all the top pitchers should be toward the top of this list when it comes out.
I realize that this is for real baseball. However, catchers tend to have a lot shorter shelf life on average. Mauer is arguably the best overall catcher in MLB. McCann is a much better hitter than Martin and plays solid defense as well. I would argue all day that Mauer/McCann are better than Martin.
I agree with you that most, if not all the top spots should be near the top.
"Think of how stupid the average person is, and realize half of them are stupider than that." ~George Carlin