I have Moustakas in my minor league system already and Reyes up at the majors so I don't really need another SS prospect and was wondering if hes worth letting go and grabbing Smoak or Alonso, and if so, which would be the better option??
Well, if you don't need him for the future than you should go with what you need in the future imo. I'd try and trade Beckham (I assume this is Tampa Bay's). I think Smoak might have the better career but Alonzo I think will be better right away. Smoak could be a Teixera type while Alfonzo should be a Adrian Gonzalez type (minus the glove).
I would pick whatever player you think will be the best prospect in 2 years. You really don't have a problem until he's called up. Having a top-10 prospect at SS would probably get you a gold-mine in a trade in 2 years (if he is successful). Of course if you're skeptical of him then sell high now. I do kind of like Smoak out of the group you mentioned since he should make it to the majors quicker and with less risk (and in Arlington). He's a college bat drafted for his bat while Beckham was drafted for his tools at a premium position and he could be incredible or a bust.
Personally I would prefer Beckham over Mouse. So I would look at dropping Mouse for Smoak. I am not a big fan of Posey and Smoak couldn't have gotten a better team to play for than Texas. Having Beckham and Smoak for the future would be very nice.
"In the beginning the Universe was created. This has made a lot of people very angry and has been widely regarded as a bad move."- Douglas Adams
I was able to get Villalona for Beckham. I like having Antonelli because I feel like my MI and 2b is weak where I'm playing S.Drew and Weeks. So now I have Villalona in place of Beckham, and I'd love to get Smoak, so Im considering cutting Carrasco, though I do need pitching. So im not totally sure yet...
Antonelli is hitting sub .200 in the PCL, which is a good hitters league. I can't imagine him putting up better #s in Petco. I would lean toward Alonso because the bat is polished and his home park is a hitter's paradise. You can always trade one of these guys later for a catcher. Take the best ML player regardless of position. Your ML system is very solid