Halladay for Kinsler?

[thecougfan]

My team is stacked on offense, the weakest spots I have right now are pedroia, and an injured Furcal. With Kinsler I almost cant lose a single offensive category. My pitching now is good with halladay but I can put Percival in his place and secure at least saves with lidge, wagner and percival, Volezquez can help keep my ERA and whip low, I forgo most opportunity for Ws and Ks but I only need 6 of 10 categories to win every week (5 for pitching 5 for hitting). Is my logic flawed?

[eternalsleeper]

Well I would trade Halladay for Kinsler if your team is stacked on offence.

If you can get a second baseman of Kinslers quality you are lucky- but if you can spare this spot for a descent player while your other offense holds up then why not?

Volquez is having an unbelievable season, but he is not dependable....Halladay is (as you know) going to be one of the best pitchers in the game when he is not injured (he was hit off the head yesterday against the Pirates)

So I would do the trade since it sounds like your offense won't let you down, and neither will Halladay.

[thecougfan]

Actually I have Halladay and am considering picking up Kinsler in the trade, essentially this would create an unstoppable offense and a fight for at least 1 of 5 victories in the pitching category every week.