sox 06 wrote:Matthias wrote:How so?
Really, you just don't want to get into roster upkeep. Then you're going to have a whole problem of, "What do I do the week he plays me" along with, "Should I keep his starters active" and, "Player A got injured; what to do". The best thing to do, honestly, is to just bench all of his guys and make him a complete zero for the rest of the season.
I already said that I am not going to keep his roster up to date on a daily basis. My question is, should I put Hamels/Zambrano/Kazmir/Gonzalez back into his lineup so his team has at least someone in those spots? What I'm talking about is a one time only adjustment and after that, I won't touch his lineup again this season.
But that's unfair to the guy who's playing him now and next week. As Matthias mentioned, guys will get hurt, things will go bad. And then they come back and all of a sudden he has a competitive week. It ends up providing huge wins for some teams and hurting the few people who randomly run into a week when a couple of players are on fire.
Bench everyone, and it will be the same result for everyone playing him.