Page 2 of 2

Re: Which team would you prefer? WHIR I guarantee

PostPosted: Thu May 15, 2008 7:18 pm
by I Stumped the Schwab
thanks for the help. You both have very good offenses, but i give him a little bit of an advantage. Aside from Utley, i think your middle infield is weak spot. As for your pitching, im not crazy over it, but it is definitely better. You have too many prospects for my liking, but your pitching can keep you in it long enough to see if they pan out. Dice-K and Edinson really give you two great ptichers, but alot of the others seem like they can be inconsistent, and McGowan certainly isnt living up to expectations. its hard to give a clear cut winner, these two teams are a great matchup. Id have to wait to see if anyone cools down before a good decision is made.

Re: Which team would you prefer? WHIR I guarantee

PostPosted: Thu May 15, 2008 9:36 pm
by V
Both of you are definitely top heavy on the offense (which he wins narrowly, but a slump or injury could turn that your way). Pitching, I give you the edge, but both of you have a lot of inconsistency issues there - you should definitely be better on the wins, but I might want to consider packaging together for a top notch pitcher if possible.

Re: Which team would you prefer? WHIR I guarantee

PostPosted: Fri May 16, 2008 12:05 pm
by x2eagle18
Thanks for the help with mine

His offense is about as good as you could ever get in this format - that said, it is a 14 team league and his lineup isn't perfect - there are guys on his team that just can't possibly keep up at the pace they are currently going. As everyone else has stated, your pitching beats his easily. Overall, I expect your team to outperform his for the season. He has guys on his pitching staff that just simply aren't worth owning. While you won't beat him in the offensive categories, you should definitely stay competitive and your pitching will put you ahead

Re: Which team would you prefer? WHIR I guarantee

PostPosted: Fri May 16, 2008 4:23 pm
by NikkiSixx
thanks for the help on mine and sorry im a little late on the response. I like your team a little bit better but you could use more SB's. You are better everywhere else I would say except for speed.

Re: Which team would you prefer? WHIR I guarantee

PostPosted: Mon May 19, 2008 2:18 am
by shoelessjoetara
My Team His Team
C Benji Molina ---------------------------------------------- Joe Mauer
1B Carlos Guillen -------------------------------------------- Albert Pujols
2B Chase Utley -------------------------------------------- Kelly Johnson
3B Aramis Ramirez ----------------------------------------- Evan Longoria
SS Johnny Peralta ------------------------------------------- Christian Guzman
MI Clint Barmes -------------------------------------------- Hanley Ramirez
CI Adam Laroche ------------------------------------------- Chipper Jones
OF Johnny Damon ------------------------------------------- Pat Burrell
OF Nick Markakis -------------------------------------------- Alex Rios
OF Hideki Matsui -------------------------------------------- Ichiro Suzuki
DH David Ortiz ---------------------------------------------- Jeremy Hermeda
SP Dice-K ---------------------------------------------------- Fausto Carmona
SP Brett Myers ---------------------------------------------- Matt Cain
SP Zack Greinke--------------------------------------------- Chris R Young
SP Dustin McGowan----------------------------------------- Edwin Jackson
SP Edinson Volquez ----------------------------------------- Micah Owings
SP Randy Johnson ------------------------------------------ Scott Baker
SP John Danks ---------------------------------------------- John Lannan
SP Max Scherzer -------------------------------------------- Shawn Hill
SP Clayton Kershaw ----------------------------------------- Tim Redding
SP Homer Bailey -------------------------------------------- Joel Pineiro
CL Brian Fuentes -------------------------------------------- Troy Percival
CL George Sherrill ------------------------------------------ Jason Isringhausen
----------------------------------------- Paul Maholm
Reserves
Rafael Betancourt -------------------------------------- Pedro Feliz
Yuniesky Betancourt ------------------------------------- Luke Scott
Andy Laroche

I just added Bartolo Colon and Blake Dewitt . I dropped Yuniesky Betancourt and Rafael Betancourt.