This is absolutely cut into offense, which goes to him easily, and pitching, which goes to you easily. Led by Hanley and Pujols, along with the unstoppable Chipper, that lineup is wonderful. If he had some better arms instead of the filler types that he does, he'd be in amazing shape. Your staff is great, and the offense isn't even bad, but a few guys in there are too streaky for my liking (Peralta, LaRoche). Barmes is also scary to see despite a good average thus far.
But yeah, very close...in the end, I'd PROBABLY take his team.