B-Phill is obviously the best player in the deal, but Dunn is a killer for the Average. I would hate to trade Abreu since the Yanks are healthy now, and it's a matter of time for the offense to start firing on all cyclinders. (Well not everyone) It's a very tough deal, but I personally would do it because of ADP. Both guys your getting are either higher or in the same position than the ones your getting.
I now were too far in the season to still consider that, but that is where I usually start off.