kaiser wrote:Here's a pretty good example of how the guy proposing a bad trade to you will try to "talk you into" believing it is a great deal. Tis trade was propsed to me today (I am Cheese Ninjas, he is Ice Breakers). I have included what the other guy (Ice Breakers) sent to me to try to justify it. He is reaching at best...
I give Derrek Lee, ChC 1B to Ice Breakers
I give Matt Kemp, LAD RF to Ice Breakers
I get Alex Gordon, KC 3B to Cheese Ninjas
I get Magglio Ordonez, Det RF to Cheese Ninjas
"Lee has been struggling the last couple of weeks and Ordonez doesn't normally go off with a pop like 4 homers in 4 games but he plays consistent and never seems to get in a slump and averges .320+. Gordon is still pretty young and was a better prospect than all those 05 players like bruce,Upton,Elsbury and even Braun so it's a matter of time before he starts showing up.. might be after the all-star break and Kemp will be suspended."
I talk up my players, and how they will fit the other guys team, but I rarely talk down their players,as that insults everyone's intelligence.
Honestly, my favorite trick is to propose lopsided trades (slightly) then an hour later cancel them. Suddenly the other guy starts thinking "maybe he thinks this deal was too good" and counters.
I don't mind lowball offers, sometimes it is really just to get the ball rolling, I do hate though when the same players are offered constantly. In my one dynasty I'm set for the next decade at closer (K-Rod, Jenks, Capps, Marmol, Ray, Zumaya, Perez) but one guy keeps offering me Gregg as part of different packages for Tex (who Im not trading anyway) or Bruce.