ouch...as your starting catcher i wouldnt take any of them. get someone else for trade bait for one. is it manditory to draft two catchters? if it is i would go with LaRue.
laRue- he will not do great for u, of cource, but will do OK. look for around .254 avg, 30-35 runs, 10-12 HR's, 40 RBI's. but him not beeing good defencive catcher will get himless playing time. 20 pass balls last year, lead the majors.
"When you come to a fork in the road, take it."