I'll take Vlad easily as well. In a 5x5, I guess an argument can be made for Lee. Just look at it this way: Does either player have a comparative advantage over the other in any category. Who will win RBI/R/HR/SB out of the two? An argument could be made for both. But, who will win in BA? I don't think anyone would say Lee. Even if they produce similar numbers, you at least know that Vlad will produce a clear advantage in one statistic that I think is often overlooked. Also, in a 6+ category league, Vlad will have the clear advantage in OBP/SLG and as a result, OPS.
i always wonder if something's up with vlad physically. since he came to the angels, i see him a lot on TV and he's always walking/running like he's banged up or something. he's got that limp, i don't know if that's how he has always been, but it always gets me thinking the guy is banged up.