It depends on your goals in your league.
If your goal is to finish respectably then you don't want to touch Pujols or any first-round pick with question-marks. If your goal is to win your league and you're in a competitive league then Pujols seems like an ideal pick at his ADP. This isn't some fringe first round pick that's hurt here. His CAREER 162 game average is .332/.420/.620/1.040 with 44 doubles, 42 hr's, 126 runs, 128 rbi's, and 6 sb's. Those are INSANE numbers and he's been doing that sort of thing every single year. His 'down year' last year ranked him #21 overall - so barring the injury taking him out of the games entirely you'd be hard-pressed to find a more reliable producer.
Hope springs eternal
grows like ivy on the vine
then dies in the fall
--Haiku for a Cubs Fan, The Loveable Losers