Liriano over Lincecum and Gallardo? LOL Maybe when he pitches a full season without his arm falling off. His mechanics were horrible and he threw way too many sliders. He can change both of those things but you are looking at a completely different pitcher if he does.
You knock down Kazmir because of his team but not Cain? SF is arguably worse on paper going into 08 and beyond.
Jered Weaver over Hughes, Bills, Joba? The guy with far inferior stuff and injury concerns?
Felix is tier 1. He has the highest ceiling of all pitchers under 25.
I stand by my Liriano ranking. He's definitely risky but healthy I still think he's better than Lincecum or Gallardo. You're probably right about Kazmir/Cain but Cain is the the better pitcher of the two and Cain's better ERA/Whip will make up for the wins. Hughes and Joba like I said are too much of a risk to be shut down to be ranked higher, Joba especially (who may even start in the bullpen). Weaver is clearly not as talented but will pitch probably double the innings and get far more wins, Ks and have comparable ratios. Hughes wasn't great last year (his era sucked) and I think there's no way he suddenly becomes a star this year. Joba more likely but he won't pitch enough to be worth having. Oh and I agree about Felix (I like him this year) but I had him down a bit because of his moderate risk.