BoTVC Round 2 - Homer Simpson Vs. Eric Cartman

[mweir145]

[
I'd agree that the Simpsons hasn't been as hilarious as it was during it's peak (around Season 3 through Season 14), but it's still a long way from sucking.

I guess you haven't been watching the same show I have. I got a glimpse of what used to be in that movie in the summer, but The Simpsons isn't very good anymore.

That isn't to say that Homer shouldn't go a long way in this competition. One of the funniest characters ever. I never missed an episode back in the 90s.

[mweir145]

cartman is so much incredibly funnier than homer its insane...its a travesty that hes gonna lose...

how can you beat the scott tenorman episode? cartmanland? the j-lo episode?

the simpsons has never had an episode near as funny as those 3, and thats just a few of the very many

I disagree about this. I'm a huge South Park fan right now, but The Simpsons has had plenty of episodes as funny as those.

[mweir145]

cartman is so much incredibly funnier than homer its insane...its a travesty that hes gonna lose...

how can you beat the scott tenorman episode? cartmanland? the j-lo episode?

the simpsons has never had an episode near as funny as those 3, and thats just a few of the very many

Cartman isn't even the funniest character on South Park.

Randy?

[ThatDude]

Cartman isn't even the funniest character on South Park.

Randy?

Of course.

[JTWood]

cartman is so much incredibly funnier than homer its insane...its a travesty that hes gonna lose...

how can you beat the scott tenorman episode? cartmanland? the j-lo episode?

the simpsons has never had an episode near as funny as those 3, and thats just a few of the very many

While Scott Tenorman has what would undoubtedly be the most amazing ending in the history of comedic cartoon television (I actually remember where I was at and how I reacted to that episode the first time I saw it), it hardly has replay value. I would put the Squishee Bender/Pocket Knife (Boy Scoutz N the Hood) episode up against anything South Park has ever produced:

Homer: "Twenty dollars? Aww... I wanted a peanut."
Homer's Brain: "You can buy lots of peanuts with twenty dollars."
Homer: "Explain!"
Homer's Brain: "Money can be exchanged for goods and services."
Homer: "Woo hoo!" <steps towards door, trips on peanut, drops twenty-dollar bill, which floats out window and into Bart's lap>

[tuff_gong]

Tough draw for Cartman.

[pdlata]

How could you?! Haven’t you learned anything from that guy who gives those sermons at church? Captain Whatshisname? We live in a society of laws! Why do you think I took you to all those Police Academy movies? For fun? Well, I didn’t hear anybody laughing, did you?

Homer!