In a by the numbers analysis, Jroll and Hanley are both more valuable than Reyes. Hanley has done it for 2 years now, and Reyes took a Step Backwards in every almost every offensive category except steals. Including Runs, Rbis, Batting Average, sluggings, homeruns, and triples. A slight uptick in doubles, walks, and .obp.
I would probably rate them
2a. Jimmy Rollins
2b. Jose Reyes
Check out my blog at http://www.rotopulse.com for fantasy baseball analysis, injury reports, commissioner info and more.