Its always tough to evaluate value on keeper trades when your talking about young guys like butler/lind/humber because your dealing strictly in potential....
I probably wouldn't veto this... one team is trading potential studs(or duds) and some current very good players, for some slightly better current players.
If any of the trio of lind/humber/butler turns out to be a fantasy monster this trade would probably be in favor of team 2, but if they all turn out to be average or below average it will be in favor of team 1.
Like I said though, its nearly impossible to evaluate the long term actual value of the trio, but because it is a keeper league you can't discount their value.
Check out my blog at http://www.rotopulse.com for fantasy baseball analysis, injury reports, commissioner info and more.