Well, isn't that stupid
This is a pretty stupid rule, and I don't think it should be put back into the draft. How does your league determine who is a super rookie?
What about JJ Hardy? Most likely he wasn't drafted, and even though he isn't a rookie nobody expected him to do what he has done. Do they have a "super non-drafted" rule?
By the way, I think this goes in the Commisioner's section.