My question is this:
Was it in the rules before the season started? I agree that it is a stupid rule, and in any keeper league I commish or participate in, these guys were on radar and likely drafted/auctioned way before the season.
If the rule was there beforehand, post the language here for all to see. If it was instigated by commish after he/she missed out on some of these guys, and there's no stipulation for the "super rookie" grade (ie IP, # AB, ending vote tally for rookie of the year, etc) then it really doesn't make much sense.
Fantasy Baseball Forum: