Honestly this is pretty awful, and while my league doesn't have a league wide veto, if we did I would definitely do it.
Trading a nearly concensus top 5 pick who is underperforming because of little nagging injuries.(but is now killing it since being healthy) For an average draft position 50 player?
Obviously howards value to date isn't great but just because a guy goes through a slump doesn't make him worthless...
Would you allow an ortiz, utley or reyes trade for dice-k?
Or would you allow any of those for say... joe nathan? How has around the same average draft value, and around the same current value(via 5x5 leagues)
Unless there is some serious issue, I don't see trading an underperforming 4th rounder, for an underperforming 1st rounder as being a non-vetoable trade in any format. Perhaps if there was someone else of some value... but your basically looking at trading a 4th rounder for a 1st rounder straight up...
Check out my blog at http://www.rotopulse.com for fantasy baseball analysis, injury reports, commissioner info and more.