try to play in a roto league with no catcher
see where that gets you.
this is just another reason why i'm not a fan of h2h leagues. Having the ability to punt positions and or categories and still be able to compete every week.
Personally I would rather have a catcher at all times, even if it's a bad one. Like others stated, when you don't start a catcher you're potentially losing out on 4 other categories. I do understand it's from a h2h perspective, and in some weeks a catcher may verywell go 1 for 20 with no other helpful statistics. It's hard to pick a side.