And a note to those who are asking for advice: Please spell out the context of your league. How many teams in your league, do you draft from AL, NL, or mixed, scoring system, etc. It makes a big difference.
For example, if I told you my starting staff (Sabathia, Ryan Franklin, Radke, Washburn) many people would probably not think that it is very good. But...I play in an auction draft league with seven teams, and we draft from the American League Central and West divisions (nine MLB teams). No NL players, no players from the AL east. When you realize that Detroit, Cleveland, and Texas make up one-third of the pitching staffs that we can draft from, it changes the perspective.
By the way...that staff finished no less than second place in Wins, ERA, and Ratio in our 4x4 rotisserie league and represented the championship team.
Please indicate the context of your league so that we can better help you.
There's a madness to my methods...