I don't really think its all that great... he automatically loses 4 categories every week with a basic guarantee of winning 2(whip/L), and Any week where santana doesn't have a good outting, IE. his starts on 4/13,4/24 where he posted a 5.14era, and on 4/29 where he posted a 4.5 era he should lose era. Thats 50% of the time he would have lost era, so in the average matchup he will get 2.5points out of a possible 7. With a maximum of 3 points. Honestly I would love to have a matchup against a guy like that, should be an easy win nearly every time. So while I maintain my original view that it is somewhat exploitative of a grey area in the rules, its in my opinion a great recipe for losing. Punting 1-2 categories in h2h is doable.... but punting 4? not so much imo.