I already made my pick, but I want to see how others view my choice.
Prior to my selection, I had 4 hitters and 1 pitcher in my minors. They were Maybin, FMart, Adam Jones, Jeff Clement, and Scott Elbert. I decided I should select a pitcher next.
The top available players by my draft board were:
I selected Jacob McGee. My take is that Inman is somewhat of an unknown still, and some who do know him think he has too much injury risk, so I'm relatively certain I could get him next round. Somewhat of a similar situation with Erbe, except that since I have Elbert I thought I could take the larger risk of McGee's higher ceiling.
So I want to know, would you consider my decision sound? Since most of my prospects are many years away, should I have given more thought to Pie despite my hitter loaded farm? Did I shortchange Erbe's potential?