Prior is a little bit better than both
I can't agree with this. The guy is a stud, but until he has five years like Pedro, he's no Pedro.
I guess fantasy wise, I'd go with Prior over Pedro because of the innings, but I think I'd still take Schilling over Prior, unless I was in a keeper league.
I do agree Prior is a special pitcher, but there have plenty of special pitchers before who were busts. There have only been a handful of pitchers ever in Pedro's class. I think we should keep that in mind when we're comparing these guys.