An Iconic Fantasy Baseball Community
Moderator: Baseball Moderators
Scooter1027 wrote:Man, this is a close one. I have a feeling it would depend on the makeup of my team at that point and what I plan on doing the rest of the way out. I think Cain is the more "safe" pick, as other pointed out. I lean towards Hamels overall though. That 145 K in 132 IP last year is impressive. Even if Hamels only goes ~180 IP, that projects out to ~198 K. He's on a better team (in my opinion), and has more upside (again, in my opinion).
But, like I said, if I had already drafted, say, Ben Sheets, I would probably take Cain between the two to be a little safer. It's so close I think I would play it situationally.
Yoda wrote:Again, this is like being asked to choose my favorite child for me. I love them both but unless you are in a keeper, I would go with Hamels for 07.
Hobbes wrote:Yoda wrote:Again, this is like being asked to choose my favorite child for me. I love them both but unless you are in a keeper, I would go with Hamels for 07.
What makes you give Cain the edge in a keeper then, just the injury concerns for Hamels?
I have this exact dilemma, since I have them both on my 6-keeper team and can only keep one of them. I'm struggling with which one to keep.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest