hi guys, what do you prefer roto or pts league. my league is currently a roto league with the following categories
hitting AVG,SLG,RBI,HR,R,SB,OBP,Fielding % and Ks
i prefer a pts league, i think this roto format has many flaws,one yahoo doesnt allow for W and L in this format so you could theoretically have a team that would have went say 19-3, but doesnt make the playoffs bc the teams ahead of them won by larger margins, its like your awarding style pts for victories. this yr we had two teams who would have had better records then teams who made the playoffs get left out. also i feel this setup hampers you if you want to add a category you must do so on both sides, hitting and pitching
the argument i have gotten against pts is you cant accuratley value pts for pitchin gand hitting. for example how can you put a pt value on wins in comparison to a HR. as a result your potentially allowing one side hitting or pitching have more value then the other.